Derek Jeter ss
Nick Swisher rf
Mark Teixeira 1b
Alex Rodriguez 3b
Robinson Cano 2b
Jorge Posada dh
Curtis Granderson cf
Francisco Cervelli c
Brett Gardner lf
During the 2010 season, the New York Yankees lineup looked something similar to that with some variations — a little Lance Berkman here, some Marcus Thames there, sometimes a smidge of Ramiro Pena. You get the idea.
But Marc Carig of the Star Ledger writes that Joe Girardi may be looking to switch around the lineup somewhat. Though he evades the issue — “I don’t really want to get into it,†Girardi said as position players reported to camp. “But we’re not really sure exactly how our lineup is going to break.†— I don’t think it’s such a bad idea.
Last year, writers were also talking about what the optimal Yankees lineup looks like, much to the chagrin of Yankee fans who believe El Capitan should always and forever be first and foremost, the Lead Off Man.
I agree: I don’t think Jeter should lead off.
Before you vent your anger in the comments section, fans, finish reading. Below is my optimal lineup for 2011, based on who’s at the top of the Yankees’ depth chart for the coming season:
Brett Gardner lf
Robinson Cano 2b
Mark Teixeira 1b
Alex Rodriguez 3b
Nick Swisher rf
Curtis Granderson cf
Derek Jeter ss
Jorge Posada dh
Russell Martin c
Done seeing red? Breathe. OK. Here’s what I figure.
Brett Gardner gets on base. That’s what he does. Last season, dude had a team-leading .383 OBP, eighth in the AL. He steals bases — he was only caught nine times last year — and he drew 79 walks.
The guy gets on base. That’s what you want from your No. 1 spot. Sure, you want everyone to have the ability to get to first, and the leadoff spot is only guaranteed to leadoff one inning the whole game (the first, duh, follow me here) but that’s one hell of a guaranteed first batter.
That sets up your No. 2 hitter, Robinson Cano dontcha know, who led the Yankees in OPS (.914, wow) last year. He gets on base, and he hits big.
I keep Teixeira and A-Rod at third and fourth in the lineup. Both have proven themselves in… NO I refuse to say clutch situations, nuh-uh, je refuse. Both look comfortable in those positions and have shown plate discipline, creating situations where they can score runners on base and in scoring position. (A-Rod is .283/.355/.500 with RISP, Tex is .309/.436/.585.)
Swish started most of last year at the No. 2 slot, so most of his best numbers come at that point,  because he has the greatest sample size there. Next best is fourth — small sample size. But in the No. 5 spot he can put that .647 SLG from last season to use. Someone that can get on base as the leadoff man in an inning, perhaps, but also once that could potentially clear the bases with two outs.
Yes, Something-Sort-Of-Granderson still beats out Jeter in the lineup. By the time Opening Day rolls around, he’ll be newly 30, and he has plenty of great years still left in him. Sure he was eighth in BA on the team — yeah, check out the guys he was behind — but what I also like is he provides some oomph to the bottom half of the lineup.  He was ninth last season in the AL in power-speed # with 16.0, great for a lineup that still has to have the elder Jorge as DH.
It may not be wise, I’ll admit, to immediately drop Jeter to sixth or so, but it would be silly of the Yankees to continue to believe he can be relied upon as the leadoff spot as though he were still his 1996 or so self. Perhaps try him out at No. 2, shift the whole lineup I have down a notch, and see how that position suits him.
It may be more of an incentive for either player: Gardner works harder to get on base, Jeter works harder to advance the runner. Perhaps switch Teixeira and A-Rod at that point to make sure Rodriguez is still the cleanup man. I love him as No. 4. Great, productive place for him to be right now.
I just know that the Yankees should not continue to use the outdated lineup. That would be the team acknowledging that it has not paid attention to how each player has performed in the past and how they could potentially project for the future.
—–
We love Baseball-Reference.com.